Photo: SiteLogic editorial imagePlanning Law
Panels and advisory committees under Part 8 of the Act
How Part 8 of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 sets up panels and advisory committees to hear submissions on planning scheme amendments, and why early engagement during exhibition shapes the outcome.
What Part 8 provides
Most Victorian developers meet the Planning and Environment Act 1987 through permit applications and VCAT review of permit decisions. Part 8 of the Act deals with something upstream of all that: how the state changes the rules themselves. When a council or the Minister proposes to amend a planning scheme, whether to rezone land, insert a new overlay, or update a local policy, Part 8 sets up the mechanism for an independent panel to test that proposal in public before it can proceed.
A panel is an independent body, distinct from both a court and from VCAT. It is appointed under the Act, administered through Planning Panels Victoria, to hear submissions on a specific amendment and report back to the planning authority, usually the council, sometimes the Minister, that requested it. Advisory committees sit alongside panels under the same part of the Act, but they are typically appointed for broader policy inquiries, such as reviewing how a class of provision should work across the state, rather than for a single site-specific amendment.
For anyone assembling or opposing a rezoning, this is the forum that decides whether the proposal moves forward in its current form, gets modified, or gets recommended for abandonment. See Part 8 of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 for the statutory basis, and the Planning Victoria panels and committees guide for current procedural detail.
How a panel hearing runs
The process starts when a planning authority exhibits an amendment: publishes it and invites submissions from anyone with an interest. Once exhibition closes, submissions that raise or maintain an objection, or that ask for changes, are typically referred to a panel if the planning authority cannot resolve them administratively.
A panel process generally moves through a few recognisable stages. A directions hearing sets the timetable and identifies what needs expert evidence. Submitters and the planning authority then prepare and lodge material, sometimes including engineering, traffic, heritage or urban design reports depending on what the amendment touches. The hearing itself is less formal than a court or VCAT hearing: submitters present in person or through a representative, and the panel can ask questions directly. After the hearing, the panel produces a written report with findings and recommendations.
Critically, a panel's recommendations are not binding. The planning authority receives the report, decides whether to adopt the amendment with, without, or contrary to the panel's recommendations, and the amendment then proceeds to approval by the Minister under the Act. A developer who assumes a favourable panel report guarantees the outcome has misread the structure: the panel advises, and the planning authority and the Minister decide.
An advisory committee follows a broadly similar pattern of hearings and a written report, but because its brief is usually a policy question rather than a single amendment, its recommendations tend to feed into how a future amendment is drafted, rather than deciding the fate of a proposal already on foot. A developer tracking a policy review through an advisory committee should treat its eventual report as an early signal of where a future amendment affecting the same land is likely to head, not as a decision in itself.
Why timing decides who gets heard
The exhibition period is the point where an interested party has the most influence over an amendment, because it is the only stage where a submission is a right rather than a request. Once exhibition closes, the ability to be heard depends on whether a submission was lodged, and on the planning authority's decision about which submissions need panel referral.
Developers who wait until a panel hearing is convened to first engage with an amendment have already lost the ability to negotiate quietly with council officers, and they are working from a position where their submission competes with everyone else's for panel time. Early engagement, during exhibition or even before it through pre-exhibition consultation where a council offers it, is where most of the practical influence sits.
How to model it into a project
A pending or possible amendment should sit in a feasibility as a timing risk, not a binary yes or no. If a site's development potential depends on a rezoning, an overlay removal, or a policy change that is going through, or might go through, Part 8 machinery, build in a range of scenarios: adoption as exhibited, adoption with panel-recommended changes, and non-adoption. Each of those carries a different yield and a different holding-cost profile.
Treat the panel stage itself as a duration risk rather than a probability event. A directions hearing, evidence preparation, the hearing, and the report all take time, and that time sits on top of however long the planning authority then takes to consider the report and resolve the amendment. A site under option or contract during this window carries settlement risk that should be priced into the option period or the special conditions, not left as an assumption.
What to check before you commit
Before relying on any pending amendment, confirm its current stage directly with the planning authority or through the amendment tracking published by the department, rather than relying on secondary reporting. Ask specifically whether the amendment has been exhibited, whether submissions have closed, whether a panel has been appointed, and whether a panel report has been received and considered.
Read the amendment documentation itself, not just a summary. The explanatory report and the actual drafting, the proposed zone, overlay or schedule wording, can differ from how an amendment is described in planning department communications or council agendas. If a panel report already exists, read its recommendations and the planning authority's response to them, because a council's decision to depart from panel recommendations is itself a signal about how contested the outcome remains.
Engaging with the process directly
If a site's value depends materially on an amendment's outcome, engaging as a submitter, or funding a submission through a planning consultant or lawyer, is usually cheaper than waiting and hoping. A submission does not need to oppose the amendment outright; it can ask for a specific modification, such as an adjusted overlay boundary or a schedule variation, and panels regularly recommend exactly that kind of change where the case is well made.
Keep a record of every submission lodged, every direction given at the directions hearing, and the final panel report, because these documents form part of the planning history of the site and can matter later if a permit application on the same land is contested. A council's or Minister's decision to adopt, modify or reject an amendment is a matter of public record, and a landowner with a live interest in the outcome should be tracking it as closely as any other approval risk on the project timeline.
Published by the SiteLogic Editorial desk. Every fact traces to a primary source. See our standards and corrections register.
Fact-checked: 19 July 2026 · Review by: 19 July 2027
Sources: legislation.vic.gov.au · planning.vic.gov.au
Was this useful? Try the tool this post is based on:
Pro on SiteLogic. Logi: up to 60 messages a day. Logi also stops at US$15 of model cost in a Melbourne calendar month. The Developer Comms Kit and unlimited saved projects. The Strategy Lab simulator runs without Pro. Saving a scenario needs a signed-in account. $60/month or $600/year, ex GST. First 3 months are $30/month, ex GST, on monthly Pro.