Photo: SiteLogic editorial imageLand Acquisition
Option agreements versus unconditional site acquisition
A put-and-call option and an unconditional contract shift risk, timing and duty treatment differently for a Victorian development site. How to weigh the trade-off before choosing an acquisition structure.
Why the acquisition structure matters as much as the price
Two developers can agree an identical purchase price for the same site and still end up holding very different risk positions, because the acquisition structure, an unconditional contract of sale against a put-and-call option, shifts who carries planning risk, when duty becomes payable, and how long capital needs to be committed before construction can start. The structure is a feasibility decision in its own right, not a legal formality layered on top of an already-agreed price.
What a put-and-call option agreement is
A put-and-call option gives the developer, as call option holder, the right but not the obligation to require the vendor to sell the site within a defined period, and gives the vendor, as put option holder, the right to require the developer to complete the purchase if the developer has not exercised the call. Together the two options lock in a future sale on agreed terms without committing either party to an unconditional contract immediately, and the structure is common where a developer wants to secure a site while a permit application, a due diligence process, or a capital raising is still under way.
How the Sale of Land Act frames these arrangements
Option and instalment arrangements over land in Victoria sit within the framework of the Sale of Land Act 1962, which governs a range of protections and requirements around the sale of land, including disclosure obligations and restrictions relevant to certain conditional and instalment sale arrangements. The drafting of a put-and-call option, the length of the option period, the conditions attached to exercise, and the consequences of non-exercise, all materially affect both parties' risk position, so any option agreement should be reviewed against the current requirements of the Act by a property lawyer before signing, rather than relying on a template used on a previous, different transaction.
Unconditional acquisition: what it commits you to
An unconditional contract of sale, by contrast, commits the developer to completing the purchase on the contracted settlement date regardless of what happens to the permit application, the finance approval, or the broader market in the interim. It removes the optionality an option agreement provides, but it also typically secures a more competitive price, because the vendor is not carrying the risk of the developer walking away, and it can be the only structure a vendor will accept in a competitive sale process. The trade-off is straightforward: unconditional acquisition transfers planning and market risk onto the developer earlier, in exchange for price and control over the site.
Duty timing and the land transfer duty framework
Land transfer duty, the tax more commonly called stamp duty, is assessed against a dutiable transaction, and the point at which duty becomes payable, and how it is calculated where an option is involved, is set out in detail on the SRO's land transfer duty guidance, including how nomination and assignment of an option or a contract can itself trigger a dutiable transaction. An option structure introduces an additional transaction, the grant of the option, potentially ahead of the eventual transfer of the land, so confirm the current duty treatment of the specific structure being used against the SRO's published guidance, or with your adviser, before finalising terms, rather than assuming the position matches an unconditional purchase.
GST withholding and other interactions to check with your adviser
Where the site or the intended dwellings involve new residential premises, a separate federal withholding regime can require a purchaser to remit part of the price directly to the Australian Taxation Office at settlement rather than paying that amount to the vendor. This regime sits outside Victorian land transfer duty and interacts with settlement timing in a way that can differ between an unconditional contract and an option structure, depending on when the relevant transaction is treated as occurring. This is a genuinely fact-specific area, and the correct treatment depends on the structure of the option, the nature of the eventual dwellings, and the parties involved, so it needs a tax adviser's review of the actual documents rather than a general rule carried over from a different transaction.
Choosing between the two structures
Neither structure is universally better. The choice depends on which risk the developer most needs to manage at the point of acquisition. A site with a straightforward permit pathway and a vendor willing to negotiate on price might favour an unconditional contract, securing the site at a lower cost in exchange for accepting planning risk directly. A site with a more contested planning pathway, or a developer still finalising capital, is often better served by an option structure, even at a higher headline price, because it defers the capital commitment and the planning risk until the option period has proven the site deliverable.
An illustrative example
The following figures are illustrative. They demonstrate the method and will vary by site, council and timing. A site offered unconditionally at $3.2 million might instead be available under a twelve-month put-and-call option at $3.4 million, with an option fee of $50,000 paid on grant and credited against the purchase price on completion. The $200,000 premium buys twelve months in which to obtain a permit before committing the remaining capital, plus the ability to walk away, forfeiting only the option fee, if the permit is refused or the numbers no longer stack up. Whether that premium is worth paying depends on how much the developer values deferring the balance of the purchase price and the planning risk for those twelve months, against the certainty and lower headline cost of buying unconditionally now.
Practical steps before you commit
Have any option agreement reviewed against the current Sale of Land Act 1962 framework by a property lawyer before signing, with particular attention to the exercise conditions and what happens if the option lapses. Confirm the current duty treatment of the specific option structure, including whether grant, nomination or exercise triggers its own dutiable transaction, on the SRO's land transfer duty guidance or directly with the office. Ask your tax adviser to confirm how GST withholding, if it applies to the eventual dwellings, interacts with the chosen acquisition structure and the actual settlement timing. Compare the option premium against the value of the risk and capital deferral it buys, rather than treating the lower headline price of an unconditional contract as automatically the better outcome.
Published by the SiteLogic Editorial desk. Every fact traces to a primary source. See our standards and corrections register.
Fact-checked: 19 July 2026 · Review by: 19 July 2027
Sources: legislation.vic.gov.au · sro.vic.gov.au
Was this useful? Try the tool this post is based on:
Pro on SiteLogic. Logi: up to 60 messages a day. Logi also stops at US$15 of model cost in a Melbourne calendar month. The Developer Comms Kit and unlimited saved projects. The Strategy Lab simulator runs without Pro. Saving a scenario needs a signed-in account. $60/month or $600/year, ex GST. First 3 months are $30/month, ex GST, on monthly Pro.