Back to Journal
Off-the-plan buyers: valuation shortfalls and settlement risk as rates risePhoto: SiteLogic editorial image

Interest Rates

Off-the-plan buyers: valuation shortfalls and settlement risk as rates rise

A buyer who signs off the plan in Victoria locks a price and borrows later. When rates rise and valuations soften, the gap lands at settlement. This article works through the arithmetic for buyers and developers.

·Written and fact-checked . Published .·5 min read

An off-the-plan buyer agrees a price on one day and borrows on another, often two years later. In between, the cash rate and the valuer's view of the market can both move. The gap shows up at settlement, and it is the developer's problem as much as the buyer's.

Consumer Affairs Victoria's page on buying off the plan sets out the basics. A buyer pays a deposit of no more than 10% of the contract price. The contract price does not change if the property value moves during the build. If the plan of subdivision is not registered by the time specified in the contract, or the default time of 18 months, the buyer can end the contract and recover the deposit.

The same page lists the risks. Two of them are a value at settlement below the contract price and trouble getting a loan approved if the value falls or the completion date changes. Those two risks are the subject of this article.

Why this matters now

The RBA's 29 September statement says housing prices have fallen in most capital cities and new housing loans have declined noticeably. The RBA's cash rate table shows four rises in 2026 taking the target to 4.60%. The October 2026 Financial Stability Review says housing prices have declined in recent months, and that APRA's serviceability buffer, raised from 2.5 to 3 percentage points in late 2021, means recent borrowers were tested well above actual rates.

A buyer who signed in 2025 signed before those rises. Their finance will be assessed in a different market.

A worked example: the valuation gap

The following figures are illustrative. They demonstrate the method and will vary by site, council and timing.

A buyer signs a contract at $820,000 and pays a 10% deposit of $82,000. At signing the buyer expects to borrow 80% of the price: $656,000. Any pre-approval obtained then is likely to have expired before settlement.

At settlement the lender's valuer assesses the apartment at $780,000. That is 4.9% below the contract price ($40,000 ÷ $820,000). If the lender caps lending at 80% of the valuation, the maximum loan is $624,000.

  • Planned cash at settlement: $820,000 minus $82,000 minus $656,000 = $82,000.
  • Cash needed after the valuation: $820,000 minus $82,000 minus $624,000 = $114,000.
  • The shortfall is $32,000.

For a developer with 40 buyers, if half face the same shortfall, the combined gap is 20 × $32,000 = $640,000. Some buyers will find the money. Some will ask the developer to renegotiate. Some will default, and the developer will have to enforce the contract or resell into a softer market.

Consumer Affairs Victoria lists a value at settlement below the contract price as a risk of buying off the plan.

A second gap: serviceability

Lenders test borrowers against a rate above the actual rate. Take the $656,000 loan. If the assessed rate is the loan rate plus 3 percentage points, and the loan rate was 5.20% at signing and 6.20% at settlement, the assessed repayment moves from about $4,905 a month (8.20%) to about $5,373 (9.20%). That is $468 more a month.

A buyer who would have passed the test at signing may not pass at settlement without a larger deposit, a co-borrower or a smaller loan. Whether a lender re-tests at settlement, and on what basis, depends on its policy. Ask early.

A third cost: delay

A shortfall can reduce proceeds, and it can delay them. Suppose 4 of the 40 buyers need an extra three months to arrange cash or a different lender.

Each of those settlements would normally repay $820,000 minus $82,000 = $738,000 of the facility, because the deposit is already held. Four of them delay $2,952,000. At the illustrative 8.10% holding rate, three months of extra interest is $2,952,000 × 8.10% × 0.25 = $59,778.

That figure does not include legal costs, extension fees under the contract or any change in the market while you wait. It does show why a settlement register belongs in the feasibility, with a line for delayed settlements next to the line for finance cost.

What a developer can do

  1. Track the buyer book. For each contract, record the price, deposit, original pre-approval, lender and expected settlement date. Review it each quarter, not at the end.
  2. Stress the whole book. Apply a 3%, 5% and 8% valuation fall and calculate the gap per buyer and in total.
  3. Contact buyers before settlement notices go out. A buyer who learns of a shortfall three months early has more options than one who learns on the day.
  4. Hold the 18-month default in view. If the plan of subdivision will not register on time, the buyer may be entitled to end the contract. Check the specific contract and take advice.
  5. Talk to your own lender. Settlements fund the facility repayment. A cluster of failed settlements can breach conditions in the facility.

What a buyer should check

Get a firm completion date in writing from the developer, as Consumer Affairs Victoria advises. Ask your lender how it values off-the-plan property at settlement and whether it re-tests serviceability. Consider how you would cover a shortfall if the value came in below the price.

Seek independent legal advice before signing or before relying on any right in the contract.

This article is general information and not financial advice.

Published by the SiteLogic Editorial desk. Every fact traces to a primary source. See our standards and corrections register.

Fact-checked: 3 October 2026 · Review by: 3 January 2027

Sources: consumer.vic.gov.au · rba.gov.au · rba.gov.au · rba.gov.au

Our standards·

Share this article

Get new articles by email

Weekly digest of new articles. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Was this useful? Try the tool this post is based on:

Pro on SiteLogic. Logi: up to 60 messages a day. Logi also stops at US$15 of model cost in a Melbourne calendar month. The Developer Comms Kit and unlimited saved projects. The Strategy Lab simulator runs without Pro. Saving a scenario needs a signed-in account. $60/month or $600/year, ex GST. First 3 months are $30/month, ex GST, on monthly Pro.

See Pro pricingFree tier stays free.