Photo: SiteLogic editorial imageInterest Rates
Fixed or variable at 4.60%: how to compare, with arithmetic
A method for comparing a fixed and a variable home loan after four cash rate rises, with three-year arithmetic across several rate paths. It sets out the costs and trade-offs and makes no recommendation.
The RBA announced a rise in the cash rate target to 4.60% on 29 September, effective 30 September. It was the fourth rise of 2026. Variable-rate borrowers have faced four rises in the cash rate this year, and some will be asking whether to fix.
This article does not answer that question for anyone. It shows how to compare the two on paper. The Board meets on 2 and 3 November and announces its decision on 3 November, and nobody outside the Board can say what it will decide, so the comparison has to work without that guess. The method below applies whatever happens.
What the two loans do
Moneysmart describes a fixed rate as one that stays the same for a set period, usually between one and five years. Repayments do not change during that time, whether market rates rise or fall. When the period ends, the loan usually moves to the lender's variable rate, called the revert rate, unless you switch or agree another fixed term.
A variable rate can go up or down. The lender decides whether to change it and by how much. Moneysmart notes that cash rate changes may influence variable rates but lenders can also change rates for other reasons.
It lists the trade-offs. Fixed loans give certainty and protection from rises during the term. You do not benefit if rates fall, a break fee may apply if you switch, sell or repay early, and some fixed loans have fewer features such as offset accounts or extra repayments. Variable loans are easier to refinance and usually allow extra repayments, but repayments can rise, which can make budgeting harder.
A worked example
The following figures are illustrative. They demonstrate the method and will vary by lender, loan and timing. They are not quotes.
A $700,000 loan over 30 years, principal and interest. The variable rate is 6.20%. A three-year fixed rate is 6.45%, a 0.25 point premium for certainty.
- Variable repayment at 6.20%: about $4,287 a month.
- Fixed repayment at 6.45%: about $4,401 a month, which is $114 more.
The simple comparison stops there. A better one counts the interest paid over the fixed term under several variable paths. In the table below the variable rate changes at the start of year two and holds through year three, and repayments are recalculated on the remaining balance and term. Interest paid is the sum of repayments over 36 months, plus the balance still owing at the end, less the original $700,000.
| Variable rate path | Interest over 3 years | Fixed compared with variable | |---|---|---| | Fixed at 6.45% | $133,148 | not applicable | | Variable stays at 6.20% | $127,884 | Fixed costs $5,265 more | | Variable falls 0.50 to 5.70% | $120,962 | Fixed costs $12,187 more | | Variable rises 0.50 to 6.70% | $134,814 | Fixed saves $1,666 | | Variable rises 0.50 in year two, 0.25 more in year three | $136,525 | Fixed saves $3,377 | | Variable rises 3.00 to 9.20% | $169,548 | Fixed saves $36,400 |
The last row follows Moneysmart's suggestion to see what your costs would be if rates went up by 3%. The variable repayment in that row would be about $5,700 a month from the start of year two, against $4,401 on the fixed loan.
Find the break-even
The stay-flat row shows the price of certainty: $5,265 over three years. The variable loan has to cost you that much more before the fixed loan wins.
In this example, a rise of about 0.4 points at the start of year two, held through year three, is the break-even. Below that, variable costs less. Above it, fixed costs less. Any change in the premium moves the break-even. If the fixed premium is 0.50 points instead of 0.25, the break-even roughly doubles.
The break-even is a number about the market, not about you. Your own question is whether you can carry the worst row on the table. Moneysmart's guidance is to be realistic about what you can afford, and to consider how you would manage if rates rose, especially if you are borrowing close to your limit.
What the table leaves out
Break fees. If you sell or refinance during the fixed term, the lender may charge a fee. Ask for the break cost formula in writing and run it on an assumed rate fall.
The revert rate. After the fixed period the loan moves to the lender's variable rate. Ask what it is now, how far it sits from the lender's best variable rate and whether you can switch without cost.
Features. Offset accounts and extra repayments can reduce interest on a variable loan. Check what each loan allows. Moneysmart notes some fixed loans have fewer features.
Switching costs. Its guidance on switching says variable rates on the market can differ by more than 2%, and lists a break fee on a fixed loan, discharge, application and switching fees, and possible lender's mortgage insurance. A cheaper variable rate may beat a fixed rate before you start.
A split loan. Moneysmart describes splitting a loan into fixed and variable parts. Run the arithmetic for each part, and check the fees on both.
What decides it
Three inputs decide the comparison: the premium over the variable rate, how long you expect to hold the loan, and how much a rise would strain your budget. The RBA's 29 September statement does not commit to a path. It says the Board will be attentive to data and may raise the rate further if needed. Nobody outside the Board knows the next move, so a comparison that depends on guessing it is not much use.
Use the table with your own numbers. Put your loan balance, your lender's variable and fixed rates, and your remaining term into Moneysmart's mortgage calculator, then compare several variable paths yourself.
This article is general information and not financial advice.
Published by the SiteLogic Editorial desk. Every fact traces to a primary source. See our standards and corrections register.
Fact-checked: 3 October 2026 · Review by: 3 January 2027
Sources: moneysmart.gov.au · moneysmart.gov.au · rba.gov.au · rba.gov.au
Was this useful? Try the tool this post is based on:
Pro on SiteLogic. Logi: up to 60 messages a day. Logi also stops at US$15 of model cost in a Melbourne calendar month. The Developer Comms Kit and unlimited saved projects. The Strategy Lab simulator runs without Pro. Saving a scenario needs a signed-in account. $60/month or $600/year, ex GST. First 3 months are $30/month, ex GST, on monthly Pro.