Photo: SiteLogic editorial imageFeasibility
Development margin versus IRR: which metric to trust
Margin on cost and internal rate of return answer different questions about a Victorian development. What each hides, why a short project flatters IRR, and how lenders and equity read them differently.
Every feasibility spits out two headline numbers: a margin on cost and an internal rate of return. Developers, financiers and equity partners routinely disagree about which one matters, because the two metrics answer different questions, and a project can look strong on one and thin on the other.
Two different questions
Margin on cost measures profitability per dollar invested. It divides development profit, revenue less total cost, by total development cost, and it says nothing about how long the money was tied up to earn that profit. IRR measures the annualised return on the capital actually at risk over the life of the project, accounting for the timing of every cash outflow and inflow. A project can carry a healthy margin on cost and a mediocre IRR if it takes years to complete, or a modest margin and a strong IRR if it completes quickly and recycles capital fast.
What margin on cost tells you
Margin on cost is the number most feasibility templates lead with because it is simple to calculate and simple to compare across projects of different scale. A townhouse project and an apartment tower can both be assessed on the same basis: profit as a percentage of cost. It is a useful screening tool and a useful hurdle rate for a go or no-go decision, because most developers and their financiers set a minimum acceptable margin before a project proceeds to due diligence.
Its weakness is that it treats a twelve-month project and a four-year project as equivalent if they produce the same percentage margin. A dollar of profit earned in a year is worth more than the same dollar earned in four years, because capital that is recycled faster can be redeployed into the next site sooner. Margin on cost is blind to that difference.
What IRR tells you
IRR solves the timing problem by discounting every cash flow to its present value and finding the rate at which the net present value of the project equals zero. It captures the fact that money committed early and returned late costs more in opportunity terms than money committed late and returned quickly. Equity investors comparing a development opportunity against alternative uses of their capital, other developments, listed property, or interest-bearing deposits, tend to think in IRR terms because it is directly comparable to other investment returns.
IRR's weakness is sensitivity to the assumed cash flow timing, which is itself a forecast, not a fact. Small changes in the assumed settlement date, the drawdown profile, or the timing of presales can move the calculated IRR meaningfully without changing the underlying economics of the project at all.
Why a short project flatters IRR
A short project can post an IRR that looks exceptional relative to its margin on cost, purely because the same percentage profit is earned over a shorter period. This is a mathematical property of the calculation, not evidence that a fast, thin-margin deal is automatically a good deal. A single-stage renovation-and-resell project that turns around in eight months on a slim margin can show a striking IRR, while a staged medium-density project with a substantially higher margin on cost, but a three-year program, can show a lower one. Reading the IRR in isolation, without checking the margin on cost and the absolute dollar profit behind it, can make a marginal deal look attractive and a genuinely profitable one look pedestrian.
How lenders and equity read the two metrics differently
Debt financiers are primarily concerned with the margin on cost and the presale coverage, because their return is fixed, interest and fees, regardless of how well the project performs above their hurdle. A lender wants to see enough margin buffer to absorb cost overruns and price softening before the loan is at risk, and a margin-on-cost test remains the standard serviceability and risk lens for a construction facility.
Equity partners entitled to a share of the upside care more about IRR, because their return depends on how quickly their capital is returned and redeployed. A promote or waterfall structure in a joint venture is frequently built around IRR hurdles rather than a flat margin hurdle, because the equity partner's opportunity cost is time-sensitive in a way the lender's fixed return is not.
A worked comparison
The following figures are illustrative. They demonstrate the method and will vary by site, council and timing. Project A is a twelve-month single-stage townhouse development with $2 million equity invested and $400,000 of profit, an even 20 per cent margin on cost. Because the capital is returned within a year, the equivalent IRR sits close to that same 20 per cent figure. Project B is a three-year staged apartment development with $2 million equity invested and $700,000 of profit, a 35 per cent margin on cost, a materially better outcome on the margin measure alone. But because the profit is earned over three years rather than one, the equivalent annualised IRR comes out closer to 11 per cent. On margin, Project B wins. On IRR, Project A wins. Neither number is incorrect; they are measuring different things, and a decision-maker who looks at only one of them is missing half the picture.
Which one to trust, and when
Use margin on cost as the risk buffer test: does the project have enough profit built in to absorb a cost blowout or a softer sales market before the deal turns unprofitable. Use IRR as the capital efficiency test: given the capital committed and the time it will be tied up, is this the best use of that capital relative to other opportunities available now. Movements in underlying dwelling values, tracked over time in data such as the ABS Residential Property Price Indexes, and site values reported through the Valuer-General Victoria, both feed the revenue and land cost assumptions that drive each metric, so neither calculation is more reliable than the market data underpinning it.
A feasibility that reports only one of the two numbers can still be arithmetically correct and still leave a reader with an incomplete picture. A margin figure without an IRR hides how long the capital sat at risk to earn that margin. An IRR without a margin figure hides how thin the absolute buffer is against a cost overrun. A sophisticated reader of a feasibility should ask for both before forming a view on a site, and should ask what assumptions about timing, drawdown and settlement sit behind each one.
Published by the SiteLogic Editorial desk. Every fact traces to a primary source. See our standards and corrections register.
Fact-checked: 19 July 2026 · Review by: 19 July 2027
Sources: abs.gov.au · land.vic.gov.au
Was this useful? Try the tool this post is based on:
Pro on SiteLogic. Logi: up to 60 messages a day. Logi also stops at US$15 of model cost in a Melbourne calendar month. The Developer Comms Kit and unlimited saved projects. The Strategy Lab simulator runs without Pro. Saving a scenario needs a signed-in account. $60/month or $600/year, ex GST. First 3 months are $30/month, ex GST, on monthly Pro.